Monday, August 26, 2013

Lines in the Sand

Question: In the constant war for succession between Horus and Set, which Egyptian gods do you think are on Set's side in the conflict?

It's difficult to say, really! There are a lot of factors in play, plus political situations that might change at the drop of a hat, and on top of all that Isis and Horus are both in there with their Ultimate Manipulation chicanery. But we have a few suggestions.

The most obvious ones are Set's wife and sons; they're likely to be on his side simply through family loyalty, if nothing else. They have a vested interest in his triumph, which puts all of them in a better position, and of course they may be kind of pissed off at cousin Horus for taking the throne if they believe Set's claim is better. On the other hand, they're also all at least slightly on the fence; Sobek tends to help Horus out when asked and isn't particularly hostile to anyone (but then again, do you really expect the crocodile to be much of a politician?), Nephthys was in some variant traditions (which, depending on the interpretation you like, might be true facts or later retcons by priests attempting to make Osiris look better and Set and his family look worse) infatuated with Osiris, not to mention very close to her sister Isis, both of which might be factors that sway her more than Set might like. Certainly Nephthys aided Isis in her burial and mourning for Osiris after Set killed him, which might just be sisterly solidarity but might also indicate that she isn't taking a firm side in all this. Anubis is suspect for the same reasons, thanks to the fact that those same diverging myths disagree on whether he's actually Set's son or Osiris', and he doesn't involve himself in the doings of folks above ground very much anyway.

However, Set is the grand defender of the pantheon and indeed the whole world from the depredations of Apep, so those who are likewise involved in that endeavor with him might view him as a comrade in arms as well as knowing firsthand how much he cares about his people. Ra, who is personally guarded and rescued by Set every single night, is almost certainly firmly in his came, and it doesn't hurt that Isis screwed him over with her tricksy magic spells a while ago and probably ensured that he'll never like her again. Various warlike gods who ride the boat and fight with Set, which depending on the version might include Maahes, Monthu, Khonsu, Serket and others, may also be more inclined to support him as a powerful and capable leader, especially if they were there that day he didn't go on the boat in order to go attend Anubis' birth and the Horus-led defense team got their asses handed to them.

And where Ra goes, the Eye of Ra is likely to go, so those goddesses who are or have been the Eye - Hathor, Sekhmet, Bastet, Tefnut and so on - may also rally behind Set as a result of Ra's influence. How much influence Ra still has after Isis' meddling is up to individual Storytellers to decide, though.

Oddly enough, those paragraphs look backwards: unrelated people Set hangs out with at work are the most likely to be gung-ho about getting him into power, while his own immediate family is kind of unsure and possibly working for the other side. It's a great example of a different set of Virtues at work: when you have Order, Piety, Harmony and Conviction, you're likely to believe in someone you respect with a whole and unflagging heart, but that's more important than pesky things like filial loyalty that other pantheons might hold in higher esteem.

And, of course, there are at least as many gods arrayed on Horus' side in this very, very old argument. Gods probably can and do change sides all the time, based on who they think is winning, new information they learn about one or the other being a douchebag or the manipulative meddling of the social powerhouses among them. It's a Game-of-Thrones-esque labyrinth of byzantine intrigue, where everything might change at a moment's notice and the only surety is that you don't want to end up on the losing side at the wrong moment.

5 comments:

  1. So despite his reputation Set is a benign force most of the time?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Since he protects Ra - and thus everybody - from Apep every day, he's a necessary and benevolent force in that way. Of course, he also murdered Osiris the king and tried to take his throne, which is why he and Horus are fighting the first place, so he's also not all hearts and butterflies.

      Set really got syncretized heavily with the northern god Sutekh around the time of the Hyksos invasion, which is when he started to pick up foreign negative connotations. The Greeks associated him with Typhon later, which for them made him firmly evil, and that's where his popular image has been ever since.

      Delete
    2. He's pretty much an asshole who is primarily interested in taking the throne for himself, or giving it back to Ra. But besides that, he is definitely fighting on the side of the Gods and would be less likely than many other Egyptian gods to ever side with the Titans.

      All that Set = Evil stuff, especially that whole Settite Vampire Clan thing is a bunch of bad PR. It's pretty much what you get with low Charisma while people with tons of Manipulation are throwing out Rumormills + Commandment about you :)

      Delete
  2. I think a good example for why Anubis and Set will (regardless of relation) always have some porblems working together is that Anubis burned his skin with a glowing hot iron in the Papyrus Jumilhac for interrupting Osiris' burial rites. Remember kids: There's a difference between those precious father-son-moments and kid-on-parent abuse with a glowing hot iron for God's sake!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Anubis just feels really strongly about burial rites, you guys. He is not kidding around.

      Delete